profile

Whole Leader Dispatch

Authenticity - The Power of Being Genuine

Published 10 months ago • 5 min read

Dear Reader,

Authenticity in leadership sounds simple—just be yourself, right? But in practice, it’s far more complex. It’s about being real in a way that builds trust, strengthens relationships, and leads to better outcomes. It’s about balancing honesty with emotional intelligence—expressing what needs to be said in a way that moves people forward.

This is a lesson I’ve learned the hard way.

I can recall plenty of situations I’d love a do-over on, moments where I reacted rather than responded. My reaction was driven by my instinct to immediately fix the problem—to jump into action, solve the issue, and move forward. With experience comes wisdom, and if I could go back, here’s what I’d tell my younger self.

One particular moment stands out. A direct report shared an issue between my team and a colleague’s team. The minute I heard there would be delays, the need to deliver bad news to principals, and major adjustments ahead, my blood pressure spiked and my “I know the right way to fix this” instincts kicked in. What I didn’t do was pause, gather more perspectives, or get curious about what was really happening. Instead, I called an emergency meeting, made it clear the issue had to be resolved, and laid out my own solution.

The result? A disempowered team stuck implementing changes that didn’t actually solve the root problem. I hadn’t created space for different viewpoints. I didn’t check my own assumptions. And I certainly didn’t tend to relationships or fairness in how I was leading. I was lucky—I had built enough trust and credibility that my colleagues gave me grace. I apologized when I realized my mistake, but the cultural damage took time to repair.

That’s why this edition of Whole Leader Dispatch is all about leading with authenticity—alongside other emotional intelligence skills. Here’s what’s inside:

📌 My latest blog explores the Genos Model of Authentic Leadership and introduces the CARE Model, a practical framework for navigating tough conversations with confidence and clarity.
​ 📌 A thought-provoking HBR article by Ron Carucci challenges us to ask: Is our emotional intelligence truly authentic, or is it self-serving?

📌 Registration for an upcoming Whole Leader Webinar where I will guide participants through an exploration of how emotional intelligence (EI) can transform your leadership approach and empower your team to achieve outstanding results.​
​ 📌 Curated resources, including Brené Brown’s Dare to Lead and two must-listen podcast episodes on leading with courage and authenticity.
📌 The CARE Model Playbook, a free leadership tool to help you approach difficult conversations with structure and emotional intelligence.

I hope this edition helps you pause, get curious, and lead with greater clarity and intention—especially in those moments that trigger your “fix-it” instincts.

Let’s lead with clarity, courage, and connection.

Clear eyes. Full hearts.

Paula

Field Report: Leadership Insights

​Ron Carucci’s Harvard Business Review article explores the misuse of emotional intelligence, particularly when leaders unknowingly manipulate emotions to serve their own needs rather than fostering genuine connections. He identifies three common ways emotional intelligence can be inauthentic, highlighting the need for self-awareness and honest reflection to ensure that leaders use their emotional intelligence ethically and effectively.

Key Takeaways:

  • Empathy vs. Hero Syndrome: Leaders may believe they are being empathetic but instead rescue employees to fulfill their own need to feel indispensable, rather than fostering accountability and growth.
  • Active Listening vs. Validation-Seeking: Some leaders feign active listening while subtly steering conversations to confirm their own perspectives, prioritizing being "right" over genuine openness to diverse viewpoints.

Self-Awareness vs. Approval-Seeking: Leaders who frequently solicit feedback may actually be seeking reassurance rather than constructive criticism, putting the burden of their insecurities on their teams. your content here...

Paula's Substack

In my latest post, I explore what it truly means to lead with authenticity—beyond the buzzword. Authentic leadership isn’t just about “being yourself” or blunt honesty; it’s about expressing yourself in ways that are clear, constructive, and considerate. I break down the Genos Model’s seven behaviors of authentic leaders and introduce the CARE Model, a practical framework for navigating tough conversations with emotional intelligence. Plus, I share a real-world coaching story that proves why authenticity isn’t just a leadership trait—it’s a game-changer for trust and performance. Read the full post to discover how leading with authenticity can transform your team and your impact.

Spotlight on Whole Leader Lab Services: Lead, Empower, and Thrive with EI

In our commitment to fostering authentic and impactful leadership, we're excited to spotlight an upcoming opportunity from Whole Leader Lab. Join the free Whole Leader Webinar to explore how emotional intelligence (EI) can transform your leadership approach and empower your team to achieve outstanding results.

Why Attend?

  • Unlock the Power of EI: Understand the neuroscience behind emotional intelligence and its pivotal role in effective leadership.
  • Practical Insights: Learn actionable strategies to enhance self-awareness, empathy, and resilience in your leadership practice.
  • Interactive Experience: Engage in an interactive session designed to provide tools for personal and professional growth.

Event Details:

  • Date & Time: March 22 at 3:00 pm CST
  • Registration: Secure your spot today by registering HERE. (You'll gain lots of value in an hour!)

Don't miss this chance to elevate your leadership skills and create a thriving team environment. Take the first step toward amplifying your impact in 2025!

​

Dispatch Toolkit

Book

Dare to Lead by Brené Brown

One of my all-time favorites, this book is a must-read for leaders looking to embrace vulnerability, courage, and authenticity in the workplace.

Brown explores how daring leadership fosters trust, innovation, and meaningful connections.

Podcasts

I couldn’t narrow to one listen for this Dispatch, so I’m sharing a few really insightful ones.

​

Introducing the CARE Model Playbook:

A Leadership Tool for Tough Conversations

Difficult conversations are an inevitable part of leadership, yet many leaders avoid them due to fear of conflict or uncertainty about how to navigate them effectively.

This tool helps leaders define the core issue clearly, invite collaboration, strengthen trust, and ensure fairness in decision-making. With practical prompts and key phrases, the CARE Model Playbook empowers leaders to turn challenging conversations into opportunities for alignment, growth, and stronger relationships.

​

Connect & Engage

Authenticity is a cornerstone of great leadership, but we all have areas where we can improve. According to the Genos Emotional Intelligence Model, authentic leaders demonstrate seven key behaviors—which one do you most want to strengthen?

🔹 Openly Expressing Thoughts, Feelings, and Opinions – Speaking honestly while staying aware of impact.

🔹 Expressing Oneself in a Way That Is Sensitive to Others – Balancing candor with care.

🔹 Facilitating Robust, Open Debate – Encouraging different perspectives without fear of conflict.

🔹 Being Open and Honest About Mistakes – Owning missteps and leading with humility.

🔹 Honoring Commitments and Keeping Promises – Following through to build trust.

🔹 Encouraging Others to Share Their Thoughts and Emotions – Creating psychological safety for open dialogue.

🔹 Responding Effectively When Challenged – Staying curious and non-defensive in disagreement.

Want to explore how you elevate your leadership?

If you’d like to explore elevating in your leadership, book a complimentary consultation.

I would welcome the opportunity to help you overcome the challenges that are holding you back from greater success and impact.

"The moment we choose to love, we begin to move toward freedom, to act in ways that liberate ourselves and others."

 

bell hooks · author, social critic, educator

Whole Leader Dispatch

by Paula Shannon

The Whole Leader Dispatch is ideal for leaders seeking to develop their emotional intelligence and leadership skills. Subscribers gain actionable insights, tools, and resources to lead with resilience, foster connection, and drive impact.

Read more from Whole Leader Dispatch

Dear Courageous Leader, As we move closer to Christmas, I find myself returning to a quieter question than usual. Not what needs to be done, solved, or resolved, but how am I showing up. The Advent season invites us into a different rhythm. One that values nearness over noise and presence over performance. It asks us to pay attention to how we are being with ourselves and with one another, especially when the pressure is real. This season has been asking me to loosen my grip on performance...

10 days ago • 5 min read

Dear Courageous Leader, Advent is the season of waiting, but not in the passive sense. It is the season of becoming. This week, I’ve been reflecting on a framework that has shaped my life again and again, often without my permission: Order → Disorder → Reorder. Richard Rohr calls this the universal pattern of transformation. Its wisdom reverberates across every major spiritual tradition. It’s also the rhythm of adult development and the reality of leadership. Here’s how he describes it: Order...

21 days ago • 4 min read

Dear Courageous Leader, The first week of Advent invites us into watchfulness, not the anxious, bracing kind, but the quiet, courageous kind. Watchfulness asks us to be awake to our lives, to ourselves, and to what is slowly emerging beneath the noise. This invitation took on new meaning for me last week in Santa Fe. I had the privilege of learning with Susan David, the creator of Emotional Agility, alongside 49 extraordinary coaches, consultants, and deeply human leaders at the Modern Elder...

27 days ago • 3 min read